top of page
8-Perf: Vistavision and IWerks

8-Perf: Vistavision and IWerks

Writer: Mark Wiggins
Mark Wiggins
6 days ago
9 min read

Two very different approaches to large-format cinematography, sharing a common number of perforations.


When we talk about large-format cinematography, certain formats tend to dominate the conversation. Todd-AO, IMAX and, more recently, the resurgence of VistaVision have all attracted considerable attention. Yet there is another format with a fascinating history and an equally interesting engineering story: 8-perf.


The interesting thing about eight-perf is that it describes two quite different approaches to filmmaking. VistaVision uses 35mm film running horizontally, exposing eight perforations per frame. At the other end of the scale, 8/70 uses 65mm film running vertically, also exposing eight perforations per frame.

They share a perforation count, but their origins, engineering and intended applications are very different.


One was developed to improve the quality of conventional theatrical filmmaking. The other evolved into a specialist large-format system designed for giant-screen cinemas, museums, theme parks and motion-simulation attractions.

To understand how these systems came about, it is worth looking at the different engineering paths that led to them.


VistaVision: Turning 35mm on its side


The idea of running 35mm film horizontally through a camera was not new when Paramount introduced VistaVision in 1954. Its origins can be traced back to the 1920s, when the William P. Stein Camera Company developed equipment for William Fox’s experimental Nature Color process.

The original Stein cameras were designed to record two separate four-perf images simultaneously, one through a red filter and the other through a green filter. The images could subsequently be combined to produce a colour picture.


The colour process itself was unsuccessful, but the cameras represented an interesting piece of engineering. They already transported the film horizontally, advancing eight perforations at a time.


In the early 1950s, Paramount Pictures was looking for ways to improve the quality of its theatrical presentations. Hollywood was responding to the growing popularity of television, and widescreen processes were becoming increasingly important.


Rather than simply adopting an anamorphic system, Paramount explored the possibility of obtaining a larger negative by using the full horizontal width of 35mm film.


The old Stein cameras offered a starting point.

The cameras were acquired and modified, with the divider separating the original two image areas removed. This allowed the entire eight-perforation width to be used for a single image. Paramount’s camera department developed the system further, and Mitchell Camera Corporation subsequently manufactured purpose-built VistaVision cameras.


The result was a negative area approximately 2.66 times that of conventional four-perf 35mm.

VistaVision made its theatrical debut with White Christmas in 1954. One of its major practical advantages was that the larger horizontal negative could be optically reduced to conventional vertical four-perf 35mm prints. Cinemas did not need to install an entirely new projection system to exhibit the films.


Vistavision camera in the 1950s


The format offered a significant improvement in negative area while retaining a relatively straightforward route to theatrical distribution.

VistaVision also found another important application in visual effects. The larger negative provided additional image information, helping to preserve detail through the optical printing and compositing processes that were an essential part of visual effects production.


Although its original theatrical use declined, VistaVision never entirely disappeared. Its continued use in visual effects, followed by its more recent revival in contemporary filmmaking, has ensured that the format remains part of the cinematographer’s vocabulary.


The Beaumont Vistavision camera.


The other eight-perf: 65mm running vertically


While VistaVision took the familiar 35mm gauge and turned it sideways, another approach to eight-perf cinematography emerged using 65mm film.


Known as 8/70, the system uses 65mm camera negative running vertically through the camera, with eight perforations per frame. The exposed negative is subsequently printed onto 70mm film for projection.


This is not simply VistaVision on a larger gauge. The film travels in the opposite orientation, and the frame geometry is quite different.


The nominal camera aperture is approximately 52.83mm by 37.59mm, giving an image ratio of around 1.4:1. The corresponding 70mm projection frame is slightly larger, although actual projector apertures vary between installations.


The format was developed for a very different purpose from conventional theatrical widescreen photography. Its large image was intended for specialist presentation environments, where the scale of the projected picture was a major part of the experience.


But the history of 8/70 is not the story of one company or one camera. Several groups of engineers and filmmakers explored the possibilities of this film geometry, sometimes independently and for quite different reasons.


Dynavision: An experiment in stereoscopic cinema


One of the earliest developments was Dynavision, an experimental stereoscopic system associated with Linwood Dunn and Film Effects of Hollywood (FEOH).


Dunn was already an established pioneer of photographic and optical visual effects, and had explored the possibilities of 65mm eight-perf photography before the development of Dynavision.


In 1973, FEOH developed an experimental 3D system that used a single strip of 65mm film to record both left-eye and right-eye images.

The arrangement was unusual. Rather than using two separate cameras, the system placed two four-perf images vertically, one above the other, within a single eight-perf frame.

The advantage was straightforward but significant. Both perspectives were recorded on the same strip of film, removing the need to synchronise two independent cameras. The same principle also avoided the potential synchronisation problems associated with separate projection systems.


The system was demonstrated in a film known as 3-Dynavision, incorporating stereoscopic material from European productions and 65mm test footage photographed by Canadian filmmaker Colin Low.


Although Dynavision itself did not become a commercial motion-picture format, the experiments demonstrated the potential of vertical eight-perf 65mm.


There was, however, another development taking place around the same time.


ShowSphere: A different vision for giant-screen cinema


In 1969, George Casey, Lester Novros and Frank Capra Jr. founded ShowSphere, with the intention of developing large-format film technology for museums and commercial venues.


Their ambitions included building specialist theatres and producing films using 8/70.

One of the projects associated with this development was Voyage to the Outer Planets, a multimedia presentation created for the Reuben H. Fleet Space Theater in San Diego.

For the production, a 65mm Todd-AO camera was modified by FEOH to accommodate an eight-perf vertical movement. The resulting 8/65 footage was used to photograph spacecraft and planetary models, with the finished material subsequently enlarged to 15/70 for projection in the theatre’s IMAX Dome system.


This is an interesting moment in the history of large-format cinema. The production demonstrated that 8-perf 65mm could be used as a camera origination format, even when the final exhibition format was something entirely different.


ShowSphere ultimately failed to establish its planned network of 8/70 theatres. The format therefore remained largely dormant for a number of years.


However, the idea of using 8/70 for specialist exhibition had not disappeared.


Omni Films International: Bringing 8/70 to special venues


Omni Films International (OFI), founded by Fred Hollingsworth III in 1974, had already established itself in the special-venue cinema market with its Cinema 180 system.


Cinema 180 used five-perf 70mm film projected onto a dome screen through a fisheye lens. The films were typically short, immersive experiences featuring point-of-view footage from roller coasters, racing cars and other attractions.


During the late 1980s, OFI began offering a range of 8/70 presentation systems.

These included OmniVision, designed for tilted dome screens, and MagnaVision, intended for flat-screen presentation. The company also developed ESI 3-D, a stereoscopic system using two vertically stacked images in an eight-perf frame.


The first permanent 8/70 theatre opened at Seoul Land theme park in South Korea in 1987. Further installations followed in Finland, Japan, Taiwan and the United States.


The development of these systems marked an important step in the commercial adoption of 8/70. What had begun as an experimental format was now finding a place in specialist cinema installations around the world.


Iwerks: Developing a commercial large-format system


Another company that would become closely associated with 8/70 was Iwerks Entertainment.

Founded in 1985 by Don Iwerks and Stan Kinsey, the company grew out of a background in specialist film technology and entertainment systems.


Don Iwerks had spent 30 years at Disney, where he worked on innovative camera systems, including Circle-Vision 360. He was also the son of Ub Iwerks, the pioneering animator and co-creator of Mickey Mouse.


Iwerks Entertainment began installing 8/70 projection systems in 1992. Its early projectors were manufactured by Ballantyne, and the company subsequently developed its own projection technology.


It is important to understand that Iwerks did not simply inherit the Dynavision camera system. The two developments were independent. They shared the same underlying eight-perf 65mm film geometry, but Iwerks developed its own equipment and commercial applications around that format.


The company found a market among museums, science centres, theme parks and other special-venue operators. Compared with the larger IMAX 15/70 system, 8/70 offered a more compact and economical route to giant-screen presentation.


The smaller physical footprint and lower print costs made it attractive to venues that wanted a large-format experience without the full infrastructure associated with an IMAX installation.


Iwerks eventually became one of the most significant suppliers of 8/70 systems, with installations in numerous countries.



The IWerks 870 camera (image reproduced with the permission of Tyler Shields).


The Linear Loop projector


One of Iwerks’ most interesting engineering developments was its Linear Loop Film Projector.


Moving a large 70mm film strip reliably through a projector is a considerable engineering challenge. Conventional intermittent movements rely on a mechanism to advance the film frame by frame, and the demands of large-format projection place considerable stress on the film.


The Linear Loop system approached the problem differently.


Developed by L. Ron Schmidt, the technology used a continuous film transport arrangement that created a loop in the film path. It was effectively a straightened-out variation of the rolling-loop principle used in IMAX projection.

Rather than relying on a conventional claw movement, the system used a carefully controlled film loop to achieve smooth, stable transport.


Iwerks acquired the technology and developed projectors in several formats, including 8/70.

The first 8/70 Linear Loop projector was installed at the Fleischmann Planetarium in Reno, Nevada, in 1994.


The technology was subsequently recognised by the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences. In 2000, L. Ron Schmidt received a Scientific and Technical Award for the concept, design and engineering of the Linear Loop Film Projector.


It is a good example of how the development of large-format cinema involves considerably more than simply designing a camera capable of exposing a large negative. The projection system is equally important.


What makes 8/70 different?


It is useful to compare 8/70 with some of the other large-format systems.


Standard 35mm

35mm

Runs Vertically trough the gate

4 perforations


VistaVision

35mm

Runs Horizontally through the gate

8 perforations


Todd-AO

65mm

Runs Vertically through the gate

5 perforations


8/70

65mm

Runs Vertically through the gate

8 perforations


IMAX 15/70

65mm

Runs Horizontally through the gate

15 perforations


The difference between these systems is not simply the amount of film used. Each format reflects a different approach to image capture and presentation.


VistaVision increased the negative area by turning 35mm film sideways. Todd-AO used 65mm film with a five-perf vertical frame to create a large theatrical widescreen image. IMAX adopted horizontal 65mm transport and fifteen perforations per frame to produce an exceptionally large image.


8/70 took another route, using vertical 65mm transport and eight perforations per frame.

One observation I find particularly interesting is that vertical eight-perf 65mm can be understood as a natural development from conventional four-perf 35mm.


Both use vertical film transport. The eight-perf 65mm arrangement retains that basic direction of movement while expanding the film gauge and image area. It is not simply a scaled-up version of 35mm, because the film dimensions and perforation pitch differ, but the underlying transport principle is familiar.


This is quite different from VistaVision, which achieves its larger frame by rotating the conventional 35mm arrangement, or IMAX, which uses horizontal transport and fifteen perforations.


There is no single route to large-format cinematography. Each system represents a different set of engineering decisions.


8-perf today


Although these formats were developed for very different purposes, interest in large-format film has not disappeared.


VistaVision has experienced a particularly interesting revival, with contemporary productions rediscovering the benefits of its larger 35mm negative. Its historical use in visual effects has also helped maintain knowledge of the format and its equipment.


The history of 8/70 is rather different. Its principal market was specialist exhibition, and the number of operational installations has declined considerably from its peak.


For filmmakers, the story is still relevant. The continued interest in unusual film formats is a reminder that technologies developed for one purpose can sometimes find a new audience decades later.


The recent use of VistaVision in feature filmmaking is a particularly good example. A format originally developed in response to television has found a place in a very different production landscape.


And while 8/70 may be much more specialised, its history demonstrates the ingenuity of the engineers and filmmakers who explored the possibilities of large-format film.


8/70: Still alive


The use of 8/70 on Brady Corbet's forthcoming feature, “The Origin of the World,” demonstrates that the format remains a viable option for contemporary feature filmmaking. Although 8/70 has historically been associated with specialist large-screen venues and attractions, its application is not limited to them. Its continued use on a major feature is a reminder that this unusual format still has a place in the cinematographer's toolkit.


Conclusion


Large-format cinematography is often discussed in terms of bigger negatives, higher resolution and increasingly impressive projection systems. But the history of eight-perf demonstrates that the development of film formats has always been about more than simply making the image larger.


VistaVision and 8/70 are products of different engineering philosophies. One took an established film gauge and rethought the way it travelled through the camera. The other used a much wider negative and a vertical eight-perf frame to create an image for giant-screen presentation.


The story of 8/70 is also a reminder that technological development rarely follows a straight line. Linwood Dunn’s experiments, the ambitions of ShowSphere, the commercial work of Omni Films International and the later development of Iwerks all contributed to the history of this unusual format.


Eight perforations. Two very different approaches to cinematography. And a fascinating chapter in the continuing story of large-format film.


Mark

Comments


Panasonic EVA1 Showreel

Panasonic EVA1 Showreel.  A showreel showcasing clips from productions that I have shot on the Panasonic AU-EVA1 demonstating that I can produce high-end images with the camera.

bottom of page